The Integrated Life

The Day Off That Makes You Better

Learning doesn’t stop when you put the instrument down. Rest is when much of it settles in. That’s why rest days for musicians are part of practice, not a break from it.

Learn, rest, learn, rest

Memory consolidates during rest. Most people can only hold about four new things in mind at once (Cowan, 2001; Cowan, 2010). Rest gives your brain time to process them, and then you rebuild them by coming back to the material, ideally by playing it. The more you can learn, rest, learn, rest, the faster it sticks.

This happens to me all the time. My nervous system gets overloaded, I’m overwhelmed, and I need to relax a little. So I do. I come back a day or two later, and suddenly I can play it, better than I ever have.

I see it clearly in yoga. Hold a complicated pose that’s a little uncomfortable, and at first you might only manage one breath before the quality of the pose falls apart. So you come out of it. Next time it’s one and a half breaths, then two, then four. The next day you might only manage three again, because you’re tired. Then you take a day off, and suddenly you can hold it for seven or eight breaths.

Music is the same. I want to play a passage over and over until I really have it. But when the quality of my attention starts to wane, I need to take a break, do something else, and come back to it.

It happens with students, too. They come back to lessons after a holiday and they’re just playing better. Schools build this in: we take a winter break and start the new semester fresh. Learning something new is work, because it isn’t part of you yet.

What grinding costs

Most serious players never take a day off, or they feel guilty when they do. Or they practice tired, which means practicing with less attention.

That leads to plateaus. Think about a newborn baby: everything is new, and nothing has a name or a shape yet. That’s pure discovery. When we go too far the other way, doing the same thing so many times that there’s no novelty left, we stop paying attention, and we get stuck in the patterns we already know. That’s one of the reasons we plateau. It’s also where tension, burnout and sometimes injury come from. I’ve seen it happen to players at every level, from amateurs to virtuosos I know personally.

When I’m rested, I get into the zone much more easily. My mind isn’t wandering; I’m right in the present moment. When I’m tired, my mind wanders. As a drummer, maybe my time isn’t quite right, and it’s very easy to tell when something is off.

What the research says about rest

Sleep helps the brain hold on to what you learned that day (Rasch and Born, 2013). For physical skills, the effect is more modest than once thought: a meta-analysis of 34 studies found that sleep doesn’t add new improvement by itself (Pan and Rickard, 2015). Much of the gain seems to come from rest while you’re awake.

Even short rests help. When researchers tracked people learning a new motor skill, most of the early improvement showed up during the short breaks between practice rounds, not during the practice itself (Bönstrup and colleagues, 2019). A follow-up study found the brain replaying the skill, about twenty times faster, during those same breaks (Buch and colleagues, 2021).

Rest is trust

In the Christian faith, the Sabbath is a gift, not a burden. Even God rested: “And on the seventh day God finished his work that he had done, and he rested on the seventh day from all his work that he had done” (Genesis 2:2, ESV). Jesus put it simply: “The Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath” (Mark 2:27, ESV).

Rest is trust. The work doesn’t depend only on you. It depends on a whole lot of people, and it depends on God. And if we don’t rest, we won’t be at our best for everyone who depends on us, our bandmates included.

So I practice rest. When I’m really tired, I lie down, with pillows supporting my lower back so I’m completely supported, or I sit cross-legged or on my knees, and I let everything slip away. I pay attention to my breath going in and out, and I don’t force it either way. Controlling anything, even my breathing, is the working mind, and that’s the opposite of rest. As thoughts come up, I gently bring my attention back to the breath that’s happening on its own.

Try this week

  1. Plan one full rest day, on purpose, and put it in your calendar. Don’t play any music that day.
  2. End each session well. Play the passage once, slowly and well, then stop.
  3. Let it process. After every session, whether I’ve been drumming, running or working on my businesses, I lie down for a few minutes and let everything I just did settle in. I call it processing. Try it after your practice this week.
  4. Protect your sleep the night before your hardest practice day.

Rest belongs to the same habit as attention over hours: attention is what makes practice work, and rest is what restores it. If you’re a serious player who has been grinding and still feels stuck, a plan that includes rest is part of the work I do with professional and serious musicians in My Private Studio. The free 7-Day Practice Plan keeps each day’s practice short and focused, and my talk Music as a Spiritual Tool explores how mind, body and spirit work together in practice.

I explore these ideas one-on-one with a small number of private students. If you play at a high level and want the next one, we start by finding exactly what's in the way.

Free resource

Your time and attention keep slipping away

The Stewardship of Attention Worksheet

Find where your time and attention leak, then win them back in seven days.

Get it free