The Protocol Newsletter
Don't just tell them what to practice
Sent
Every assignment should come with how to practice it, not just what and how long. A student who knows the process can improve without you in the room. This week’s post is about teaching that process. Here’s a question I hear often that isn’t in my post.
“Am I paying for the same lesson twice?”
Parents who come to Practicing Musician for private lessons often tell me some version of this, and teachers on the platform hear it from their students’ parents too: “My child enjoys lessons, but I feel like I’m paying their teacher to teach them the same thing over and over.”
My answer: unless there’s something the teacher gives the student to use between lessons, it’s genuinely hard to remember everything they were taught, exactly the way it was taught. Quality of instruction matters. But even with the best teacher in the world, a 30- or 60-minute lesson holds more new information than anyone can carry home. Most people can only hold about four new things in mind at once (Cowan, 2001; Cowan, 2010). Too much at once, and some of it gets forgotten, or practiced the wrong way all week. It’s just inevitable.
That’s not a failing of the student or the teacher. It’s how learning works. The fix is giving students something to practice with between lessons: a clear goal, a method, a way to know when it’s done, and something to listen to.
Try this at home this week
Instead of “Did you practice?”, ask “What were you listening for today?” It’s not a yes-or-no question. To answer it, your child has to think about what they practiced and teach it back to you, and that’s exactly the skill that helps them improve on their own.
The three-part assignment I give every student, and why it works, is in my post:
Read the post: Teach Students How to Practice, Not Just What If you’d like help bringing this into your own teaching or homeschool, that’s the work I do one-on-one in My Private Studio. Everyone starts with a Discovery Session.
Keep pressing on,
Jake